COLUMN

Martin Heath: Net Zero is the answer; so what's the question?

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

It's certainly been a strange few months of weather, after one of the wettest winters on record, we've just had the driest summer.

It's the kind of extreme swing scientists have been warning us about for years, and it's exactly why "net zero" matters in Basingstoke, not just in some distant policy document.

You'll have seen "net zero" everywhere lately; my mailbox and social media have been full of people claiming we don't need it.

We do, and the reasons are worth setting out plainly.

Net zero simply means humanity stops emitting more greenhouse gases than nature, or our own technology, can absorb.

It won't undo climate change, but it stops it getting worse, which is why the UK and most major economies are aiming to get there by 2050.

There are four reasons net zero is vital: it prevents climate change worsening, it delivers cheaper electricity, it frees us from expensive imported oil and gas and it cuts air pollution.

Today I'll focus on the first. I'll cover the rest next month.

Here's the core logic, and I don't think any of it is controversial.

Climate change is real and dangerous, and it's driven by human greenhouse gas emissions.

In Hampshire, 90 per cent of these emissions come from burning fossil fuels to heat and cool our buildings, power our transport and generate our electricity.

If we want to slow climate change, we must stop burning oil and gas. It’s that simple.

Doing that relies on three things happening together: improving energy efficiency (insulating and draught-proofing our homes, raising building standards); switching transport from petrol and diesel to electric and expanding public transport and cycling; and converting heating from gas and oil boilers to heat pumps and heat networks.

Electrification and efficiency reduce our overall energy demand.

Electrifying heat and transport cuts our energy needs by roughly a factor of three, and efficiency measures save another 20-40 per cent.

But, and it is a big but, electrification only cuts emissions if the electricity itself comes from renewable, zero-carbon sources.

And because so much of our energy use shifts onto the grid, our electricity demand will still rise; by a factor of three to five, depending on how efficient we are, how fast the economy grows, and yes, how much AI we end up using.

The conclusion is unavoidable: whatever we call it, the only way to get fossil fuels out of our energy system is to replace them with renewables. There's no third option.

There is a well-funded campaign trying to convince us otherwise.

Reform argues climate change isn't real, so we may as well keep burning fossil fuels.

The Conservatives accept the science but offer no coherent plan to stop burning fossil fuels, even backing expanded North Sea drilling.

I hope Labour doesn't drift the same way.

Stepping back from net zero now would be a serious and costly mistake.

If anyone spots a flaw in the logic above, I'd genuinely welcome the debate; that's how we all learn.

Next month I hope to cover how net zero will reduce energy prices, remove our reliance on imported gas and oil, and clean up our air.

(This column covers only the 90 per cent of emissions that come from fossil fuels. Farming, food and consumption make up the rest, and deserve their own column, as does the vital work of nature restoration and rewilding.)

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos