Dad voices concern at how unconscious woman was treated in Blacks

Staff tend to the injured woman. Pic by Chris Derrick Staff tend to the injured woman. Pic by Chris Derrick

A SHOPPER has complained that staff in a Basingstoke shop did not do enough to help a woman who was unconscious and bleeding after falling inside the store.

Chris Derrick has complained to Blacks following the incident last Saturday, when an elderly woman fell inside the Festival Place shop at about 2.20pm. Mr Derrick, a 42-year-old, from Brighton Hill, Basingstoke, said the woman was unconscious for several minutes, struggling to breathe and was bleeding from her head, nose and mouth. He claims the woman’s daughter was left to help her mother on her own as staff carried on with their work.

The father-of-four said: “I shouted at the staff to call the emergency services as this was serious and she was bleeding badly, but no one did anything but stare or carry on with making sales.”

Mr Derrick, who was with his four children before the incident, started to call 999 but was told by a member of staff in Blacks that the Festival Place first aid team was on its way. He added: “When the woman’s daughter asked for something to cushion her mother’s head, again, staff did absolutely nothing to assist. Instead, I collected some items of clothing from the rails and fashioned a crude pillow from them.”

Mr Derrick emailed Blacks’ customer services, complaining about the way staff responded to the incident. He said: “I have never witnessed such a lack of compassion, and feel so disgusted by what I saw that I cannot let this lie.”

However, a member of staff at the store and the centre director of Festival Place have both defended the way in which the incident was handled.

David, a supervisor at Blacks, who declined to give his surname, said: “The manager was very happy with the way the staff dealt with the incident.

“The centre staff (from Festival Place) said we did everything correctly as well. The family of the casualty were completely happy as well and that man was the only person there who had any issue.”

Steven Connolly, centre director at Festival Place, said Festival Place staff were called to the scene at 2.20pm, and upon arrival found that an ambulance had already been called by staff in Blacks. It arrived six minutes later.

He added: “If she was in an area away from members of the public, it wouldn’t be unusual for members of staff to carry on serving. From all the information I have, Blacks did everything that was expected of them.”

A statement from Blacks customer services said: “We acknowledge we have received the complaint from the customer and this has been passed on to the relevant team to investigate.”

Comments(13)

Alfie The Dog says...
1:24pm Fri 1 Mar 13

The manager of Blacks was happy how things were handled, Festival Place staff said that everything was done correctly.

Even the family of the casualty were 'completely happy'.

Some random passerby isn't happy.... well so what?

I doubt that he had any idea what was actually going on, the fact that not all the shop staff stopped serving customers is not an indication of a 'lack of compassion'.

This is a non story.

jbee37 says...
1:28pm Fri 1 Mar 13

By the looks of it, the staff at Blacks did the right thing by calling the emergency services and then try to comfort the stricken woman as best they could. It would be a shock for most people seeing someone collapse and perhaps the rest of the staff carried on serving so as not to cause a scene and encourage rubber-neckers. The thing that bothers me though is the complainant standing there taking pictures instead lending his own first aid experience, but then again, perhaps he didn't have any either?

Sam_Walker123456 says...
3:26pm Fri 1 Mar 13

Sounds to me like Chris Derrick panicked while the staff stayed calm, ignored his hysterical shouts and got on with sorting things out to the satisfaction of everyone else.

robertspet8 says...
3:46pm Fri 1 Mar 13

Sam_Walker123456 wrote:
Sounds to me like Chris Derrick panicked while the staff stayed calm, ignored his hysterical shouts and got on with sorting things out to the satisfaction of everyone else.
We do not know that he panicked but we do know that he said, “When the woman’s daughter asked for something to cushion her mother’s head, again, staff did absolutely nothing to assist. Instead, I collected some items of clothing from the rails and fashioned a crude pillow from them.”
So he clearly did not have any knowledge of basic first aid. When somebody is unconcious the most important thing is to keep the airways free by putting the person into the recovery position. By lifting the woman's head with a cushion it could have constrict the airways and prevented fluids from draining out of her mouth and nose causing her to choke.
Chris Derrick was clearly upset and only trying to help but his actions could have had tragic consequences.
Perhaps the lesson is that we should all learn or brush up on first aid.
I hope the woman makes a full recovery.

ELLIS17 says...
2:20pm Sat 2 Mar 13

First Aid training is forever changing its approach, so no matter if we all brush up, as I found out only recently on attending a First Aid advanced course we could still be behind current thinking. The important story now, has the Lady made a full recovery since this incident?

BugBear says...
4:06pm Sat 2 Mar 13

One has to be careful when rushing to help someone in today's sick compensation culture society, many with no self respect would jump at the chance to make a few quid by claiming the help given actually made matters worse. I expect the shop employees, being just normal people like the rest of us and not some form of evil lower beings did what any of us would do and Mr.Derrick on the other hand saw an opportunity to get the picture he took in the paper.

JJ38JJ says...
8:14am Mon 4 Mar 13

Perhaps Mr Derrick should have asked staff in neighbouring shops what they would have done. Like the trendy Apple shop opposite manned by teenagers who look like they ooze first aid know how. Sounds like he has something against Blacks who he believes should offer a service over and above simple retail.

jonone says...
12:06pm Tue 5 Mar 13

Good point laurence86, think the woman would have a good case against both the Gazette and Mr Derrick for invasion of privacy.

laurence86 says...
12:41pm Tue 5 Mar 13

Your right Jonone, she should start proceedings against them even if it’s just to formally show disapproval

Sam_Walker123456 says...
5:08pm Tue 5 Mar 13

laurence86 wrote:
Your right Jonone, she should start proceedings against them even if it’s just to formally show disapproval
The lady involved has not been identified by The Gazette or by Mr Derrick so there is no invasion of privacy and therefore no grounds for proceedings. Newspapers normally ask for permission of people to use photographs of them but in this instance the photograph does not show anything which will identify her to anybody but her close friends and family who will already be aware of this distressful incident. All it shows is a person, probably a woman, being attended to. So no invasion of privacy. And why do you think that she disapproves and would want to take proceedings anyway?
Regarding your earlier point, 'Badly done Gazette, please stick to reporting the facts not trumped up articles.' Where did The Gazette not report the facts and what is trumped up about the article? You are encouraging the lady to take action for something which did not happen but I would say that The Gazette has a case against you for libel!
Unsurprisingly you also do not know how newspapers work. The reporters do not write their own headlines, other people are employed to do that. They are trying to grab our attention and they use many tricks to do this. One trick is to have a headline which can be read more than one way - is he the woman's dad or just a dad? Another trick is to give some character to the person - in this instance if they said 'man' we would have been less likely to read the article. But the only thing they have which differs Mr Derrick from any other man is that he is a 'father of four', but I suppose this was too long and they used 'dad' instead. Personally I would have used 'Interferring busy body panics and accuses shop staff of ignoring unconcious woman.' That would grab the headlines. But I might have found myself in court for defamation of character.

red teacosy says...
7:23pm Tue 5 Mar 13

I went into the 'pound shop' with a toothache last week, and the staff just carried on as if nothing had happened!!,

Harryguild1960 says...
11:05pm Thu 7 Mar 13

What do you expect the staff to do Mr Derrick?? Intervene and possibly make a bad situation worse. They contacted Festival Place staff, who are fully first aid trained and ambulance medics arrived 6 minutes later. I'm sure Mr Derricks intervention did not help and indeed could have made the situation worse. What sort of a sick person actually takes photos of the incident?? Mr Derrick, I would suggest, whatever your personal opinions, to mind your own business and go away. I'm sure you were not the only member of the public in the store ... Why are you the only person getting involved? The staff obviously followed correct procedure by alerting Fesival Place staff and calling an ambulance ... the ambulance arriving in just 6 minutes shows this was done in a timely manor. Getting hysterical, angry and standing complaining really doesn't help in a situation like this ... just imagine if the staff had personally intervened and injured this lady more? Leave it to fully trained medics, stay calm, keep quite & in future .... Mind your own business.

LumpyPudding says...
3:34pm Fri 8 Mar 13

If you read above “When the woman’s daughter asked for something to cushion her mother’s head" this shows that perhaps the daughter of this woman knew what she was doing and the injured lady needed a cushion below her head? The lady's daughter asked for a cusion and Mr Derrick made her one. I don't see what the problem was?

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree